Good drugstore eyeliner

Color Range

Out of the eyeliner options out there (i.e. pencils, gels, and liquids), you’ll want to turn to pencil formulas when you are hoping to achieve a smokey, sultry look. With their creamy texture, pencil liners were practically made for smudging, with many products even including a smudge sponge on one end. Fun fact: A pencil eyeliner’s ability for smudging is actually what inspired Tariq to become a makeup artist. “The reason why I’m a makeup artist is because I remember my grandmother with her eye pencil every morning putting eyeliner in her water line and smudging it to get that beautiful, raw smoky eye,” she explains. Top rated drugstore eyeliner Whether you’re a fan of graphic lines, winged looks or classic strokes, these are the best eyeliners for every skill level and preference. Perfect for wearing alone or pairing with your favorite mascara, these liners will give your eye area a major lift.

Creamy drugstore eyeliner

According to Zdunowski-Roeder, “This product will not move! Whether it’s a hot day or you’ve just watched a tear-jerker movie, this liner will stay intact.” Of all the drugstore liners she’s used, she calls this felt-pen one “overall favorite,” due to the vegan formula, highly pigmented formula, and superfine tip. Milani Supreme Kohl Kajal Eyeliner Pencil I have chosen a lot of drugstore blue eyeliners here from liquid to gel, and I’ve also chosen some eye pencils perfect to use in the waterline.

Charlotte Tilbury Rock n Kohl Eyeliner Pencil

Every product is independently selected by (obsessive) editors. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission. Best Metallic Liquid Drugstore Eyeliner One reviewer wrote: “I use it for upper eyeliner & lower eyeliner & this glides on so easily, its like creamy magic! The water proof is a plus. The first time I wore this was for our wedding day & it lasted all day & night even thought the crying & dancing. Love this & I swear by this, I will never go to any other eyeliner. This is definitely my go to & I don't want any other liner because this does NOT tug on your skin which is always 100 times better! Plus its affordable.”

Best gel eyeliner pencil drugstore

Long the domain of pencils and awkward liquids, as soon as gel eyeliners popped up over the past decade, everything changed. Whereas before eyeliner was unpredictable, rigid and melty, gel made them pliant, versatile and long lasting. And gel eyeliners come in all kinds of forms. A neat little pencil! A multi-talented pot! They really changed the eye makeup game. Here are the ones you need, now. Pigmented Formula Unlike liquid eyeliner, gel eyeliner is very forgiving, so it’s a great pick for beginners. “If you have trouble holding the pencil, shaky hands, bad eyesight, or textured lids, the gel is really the easiest liner to apply for all ages,” says Glazer. Gel liners are also typically formulated to be long-wearing and waterproof, which Glazer says is “super helpful in any category.”